Your Interpretation Of P4P

[JAB5239]

- - U Quoted the average Philpino when Manny is a one off boxing record setter of the whole world.

Sorta like U being a near record setting lower IQ for making up stuff that U know not.

What exactly does Manny being a great fighter have to do with size? Does it make him bigger, smaller, impervious to natural growth rates? Use some common sense instead of trying to inflate those you like and degrade those you dont.

[QueensburyRules]

What exactly does Manny being a great fighter have to do with size? Does it make him bigger, smaller, impervious to natural growth rates? Use some common sense instead of trying to inflate those you like and degrade those you dont.

- - What part of average stoopid does U fail to understand?

[JAB5239]

- - What part of average stoopid does U fail to understand?

Yours. Can't see it.

[Mr Mitts]

So, Bill is quoting Filipinos now is he? How's your Tagalog, Billy?

[Willie Pep 229]

It means the guy is really good.

It is a moniker used to explain the value of the lower weight classes to casuals and create talk in magazines/forums among the faithful.

[QueensburyRules]

It means the guy is really good.

It is a moniker used to explain the value of the lower weight classes to casuals and create talk in magazines/forums among the faithful.

- - The earliest P4P ranking by a forgotten Boxing writer was the excellence of any fighter for his lbs, ie Sugar Ray Robinson.

[Mr Mitts]

Let's put some poundage equivalence on 'er, yer honor.

[JAB5239]

- - The earliest P4P ranking by a forgotten Boxing writer was the excellence of any fighter for his lbs, ie Sugar Ray Robinson.

"In 1906, the Evening Star newspaper described Battling Nelson as "the fighter of the century at his weight" and said he would fight any boxer on a pound-for-pound basis"

[QueensburyRules]

"In 1906, the Evening Star newspaper described Battling Nelson as "the fighter of the century at his weight" and said he would fight any boxer on a pound-for-pound basis"

- - Obscure newspaper clippings quoting a fighter that don't reflect a consensus p4p rating that Robby first acclaimed.

[JAB5239]

- - Obscure newspaper clippings quoting a fighter that don't reflect a consensus p4p rating that Robby first acclaimed.

My point is that Robinson was not the first instance of p4p. I also remember Benny Leonard being referenced as p4p in an old newspaper article, but would have to do some research to find it. Obviously Robinson is most associated with the term, but he wasnt the first