Is Calzaghe a 2 division Champion?

[miron_lang]

------------------------------
Pls vote

[MANGLER]

The Ring belt is more important than the alphabelt belts.

[SkilledB]

ONly a champ at 168
The ring belt means nothing really, just a magazine toy, IMO he lost the fight against B-hop. He beat Eubank Clearly to win the 168 belt but really that split discision win ova b-hop for his ring belt is really nothing. if he wins a belt in a sanction( WBC,WBO etc..) then he will be a champ at 175
For now IMO just a legit champ at 168.

[mspiegelo]

The Ring belt is more important than the alphabelt belts.

the ring belt is less important than the alphabelt belts. you have no mandatory defenses and never have to face a true threat, much less a live body in your own division. prime examples of abusers:

hopkins (and im a big hopkins fan. dont get me wrong, but the guy never faced a light heavyweight after tarver for 2 years and held that ring title hostage).

casamayor- should have lost to jose armando santa cruz. didnt give cambell a rematch even though he is clearly the best challenger. at least he decided to fight jmm instead of juan diaz- boy would that have been unjust to campbell if he had fought the baby bull.

floyd- well... i think we all know this story.

[Dan...]

He holds the Ring belt for the two divisions so he is. The only one that could even be questionable is LHW but he beat the man there so he is.

[THRILLAinmanila]

If Joe is a 2-division champ, the Pacman should be considered a 5-division champ for winning the lineal featherweight championship from MAB in 2003.

[Silencers]

I think he is, he held the Ring belt at 168 and holds it at 175 so he's the man at both weights.

[Vasyl’s dad]

anyone saying no is seriously off their rocker.

[KJB]

the ring belt is less important than the alphabelt belts. you have no mandatory defenses and never have to face a true threat, much less a live body in your own division. prime examples of abusers:

hopkins (and im a big hopkins fan. dont get me wrong, but the guy never faced a light heavyweight after tarver for 2 years and held that ring title hostage).

casamayor- should have lost to jose armando santa cruz. didnt give cambell a rematch even though he is clearly the best challenger. at least he decided to fight jmm instead of juan diaz- boy would that have been unjust to campbell if he had fought the baby bull.

floyd- well... i think we all know this story.

Yeah but people are practically handed alphabet titles. Look at Andre Berto holding the WBC WW belt.... yeah.

[miron_lang]

If Joe is a 2-division champ, the Pacman should be considered a 5-division champ for winning the lineal featherweight championship from MAB in 2003.

Yes



--------