Author Mark Collings

[CarlosG815]

Wow, if that list is supposed to be in order than its awful. I would love to hear his justifications for some of his rankings. Somply baffling.

Thanks for taking the the time to type it all out though. If you type like I do it must have been a pretty tedius chore.

no problem, I type over 100 words per minute, that list took me under 2 minutes to type...

[Barn]

You will notice Naseem Hamed makes the list...

He is a British author and I noticed quite a few Brits on the list. Perhaps he is bias?

It is a decent read and has a little info on each fighter listed.

Lists are so subjective that it's hard to be critical but he does have some guys listed very high, specifically Hamed.

However, I have always thought Roy Jones to be extremely great and it's nice to see at least somebody with knowledge puts him in the top 20, as I most likely would.

I don't see how you can rate Roy so high unless you are taking H2H and skills into account.

[CarlosG815]

I don't see how you can rate Roy so high unless you are taking H2H and skills into account.

There are so many fighters we don't even know about and criteria for a list is subjective to each individual who takes the time to make the list... Roy Jones was the greatest fighter in the world for many years and yes I take h2h and visual skills into account, and how he utterly dominated nearly every man he ever faced and rarely lost a round. When Jones was at the top of his game he was thought by many to be the greatest fighter they have ever seen.

[NChristo]

Quite the list, must have some strange reasoning.

No Jofre ?, .

[Barn]

Quite the list, must have some strange reasoning.

No Jofre ?, .

lol.........

[mickey malone]

A Briton that didn't do his proper research maybe Alan Minter, Barry Mcguigan I guess Hagler is at 6 for beating an ATG in Minter

Sure he's not Irish lol.. Minter does indeed take the biscuit, especially when there's no Wilde, Fitz, Lynch, Driscoll or Winstone. Also, what about guys like Duilio Loi, Nicolino Loche, Tiger Flowers, Tommy Loughran and Maxi Rosenblooom?

Most criminally of all, he's excluded a top 10 atg imo, no Joe Gans !?!?

[RubenSonny]

Sure he's not Irish lol.. Minter does indeed take the biscuit, especially when there's no Wilde, Fitz, Lynch, Driscoll or Winstone. Also, what about guys like Duilio Loi, Nicolino Loche, Tiger Flowers, Tommy Loughran and Maxi Rosenblooom?

Most criminally of all, he's excluded a top 10 atg imo, no Joe Gans !?!?

I noticed the absence of Rosenbloom immediately, Jose Napoles also, Theres so many ridiculous placings Marlon Starling above Sam Langford thats someone most dont consider an ATG over a boxing immortal, I'd be intrigued by his justifications.

[NChristo]

I noticed the absence of Rosenbloom immediately, Jose Napoles also, Theres so many ridiculous placings Marlon Starling above Sam Langford thats someone most dont consider an ATG over a boxing immortal, I'd be intrigued by his justifications.

Napoles is there, just below Hamed. again.

[RubenSonny]

Napoles is there, just below Hamed. again.

Ahh no qualms with this list now